November 5, 2024 | 19:47 GMT +7

  • Click to copy
Monday- 10:01, 02/10/2023

Carbon offsets: giving sustainable forestry a green light

(VAN) At the margin, there are opportunities, but the price of carbon credits needs to rise
Commercial forests are not as pretty as broad-leaf forever forests, but more financially attractive. Photo:  Bloomberg

Commercial forests are not as pretty as broad-leaf forever forests, but more financially attractive. Photo:  Bloomberg

Land is a scarce resource. It is needed to produce food and lumber, provide natural habitats, capture CO₂ and even grow biofuels. Farms and villages are also intimately woven with the character of the nation. So it is no wonder that policymakers are concerned about skewed incentives to turn farmland into carbon-offsetting forests.

But — at the margin — sustainable forestry is an opportunity for the UK. The issue is that the lowest quality 20 per cent of UK farmland only produces 1 per cent of what Britons eat, says Dustin Benton at the Green Alliance. Low productivity of the land itself means a small upland farm — call it 70 hectares or so — might make £14,000 a year including subsidies.

The net present value of such an income stream — even if one assumed it grew with inflation and used a risk-free cost of capital of 5 per cent — would be about £7,000 per hectare. 

Now compare that with sustainable commercial forestry, practised by funds such as Foresight. Roughly speaking, tightly packed, fast-growing trees might deliver up to 400 tonnes of wood per hectare by 2050, and for each rotation of 35-40 years. Say the price of wood rose by 2 per cent a year, and discount the value of these crops to today, and they might approach £20,000 per hectare.

On top of that, each hectare might receive 250 tonnes of voluntary carbon credits for captured CO₂, which at roughly £20/tonne would add £5,000.

Commercial forests are not as pretty as broad-leaf forever forests, but these would be less financially attractive. They would need the price of carbon credits to rise substantially to make economic sense.

Forestry is an opportunity only for the lowest quality farmland, of course. Arable land, particularly at scale, is much more productive — and hence valuable — than small upland holdings. The fact that this sort of switch makes sense only at the margin is, lovers of rural landscapes would agree, a point in its favour.

HD

Meeting the new demands of the EUDR

Meeting the new demands of the EUDR

(VAN) Sophisticated automation enables users to send hundreds of data collection requests with a single click.

Small farmers in Europe struggle to get by

Small farmers in Europe struggle to get by

(VAN) Brutal economic situation has inflicted misery on farmers who struggle to turn a profit and forced some to look for alternative streams of revenue.

China intensifies emergency food supply amid increasing extreme weather events

China intensifies emergency food supply amid increasing extreme weather events

China has reinforced its emergency food supply in response to increasing extreme weather events and natural disasters, an official said.

Scientists dismayed as UK ministers clear way for gene editing of crops - but not animals

Scientists dismayed as UK ministers clear way for gene editing of crops - but not animals

(VAN) Advocates urge government to allow ‘precision breeding’ to combat disease, but RSPCA warns of ethical dangers.

Expectations positive, but tempered on GM wheat in US

Expectations positive, but tempered on GM wheat in US

(VAN) HB4 wheat’s USDA approval will enable Bioceres to 'move forward with nonregulated field activities for product development and commercialization,' CEO Federico Trucco said in September.

Famine and catastrophic hunger in 5 major hotspots alongside the looming La Niña_climate threat in others

Famine and catastrophic hunger in 5 major hotspots alongside the looming La Niña_climate threat in others

(VAN) Acute food insecurity is set to increase in magnitude and severity in 22 countries and territories.

Pharma and agritech groups push against biodiversity levy at UN summit

Pharma and agritech groups push against biodiversity levy at UN summit

(VAN) One contentious proposal seeks to impose 1% levy on returns from products made using genetic data.

Read more