November 26, 2024 | 01:23 GMT +7

  • Click to copy
Monday- 21:33, 21/03/2022

Cassava enterprises staggering since being ignored by General Department of Taxation

(VAN) A number of cassava enterprises have been hampered as a result of exporting cassava across borders but not being eligible for tax refunds...

65 percent of cassava production is exported via border delivery

Vietnam Agriculture News has received a complaint from the Vietnam Cassava Association on the General Department of Taxation's Official Letter 632 dated March 3, which is pushing cassava enterprises to the brink of the financial abyss. According to the letter, the General Department of Taxation directed its local branch to authenticate overseas customers, thereby halting tax refunds and collection of value-added tax arrears for cassava exporters.

Buying cassava at the factory. Photo: Vo Dung.

Buying cassava at the factory. Photo: Vo Dung.

While there are various inconsistencies in the authorization of international consumers, the existing Vietnamese legislation on value-added tax refunds has no rule requiring the signature of a foreign customer on a document to qualify for a tax refund. Cassava exporters do not have the duty or capacity to check overseas partners before contracting.

According to Mr. Nghiem Minh Tien, vice head of the Vietnam Cassava Association, cassava, and cassava-based products are mostly exported to the Chinese market via border delivery, following Decree 14, which regulates border trade operations in detail. Accordingly, border trade operations are unique to two countries that share a land border, and the two countries' border import and export rules are separate, with no legal similarities.

Cassava exports in the form of border delivery are frequently uncontractual. This is especially true in China, where dealers frequently prefer oral negotiations and are unwilling to sign contracts with cassava exporters. From there, it is feasible to divide commodities to take advantage of preferential border exchanges and avoid having to declare them to the Chinese tax authorities.

Vietnamese counterparts need information on importers (individuals and organizations) to draft contracts for tax refund documents for Vietnamese firms that do not comply with Chinese import laws. Due to the incompatibility of import restrictions governing border exchanges of products, the Chinese partner may not be allowed to deal with the Vietnamese partner.

Tien further emphasized that calculating the quantity of exported cassava is possible since cassava enterprises must make complete and accurate declarations to Vietnam's Customs and get confirmation when transporting items across the border. Additionally, the revenues from cassava exports are transferred and recorded at the bank via documents. The tax administration may thus have comprehensive supervision over the number of items shipped by cassava firms.

Does the General Department of Taxation turn its back on the cassava industry?

Currently, the cassava industry is coping with a series of difficulties caused by prolonged Covid-19, the closure of Vietnam-China border gates, official export at a low price due to fierce competition from Thailand and Indonesia, an unresponsive container supply chain, and an incurable cassava mosaic virus, to the point where the stoppage of tax refunds and collection of value-added tax arrears has put the cassava industry in jeopardy.

Without VAT refunds, cassava enterprises are at risk of bankruptcy.

Without VAT refunds, cassava enterprises are at risk of bankruptcy.

With sympathy for the cassava industry's difficulties, the Government Office issued Document No. 689/VPCP-KTTH on January 27, 2022, citing Deputy Prime Minister Le Minh Khai's directive to the Ministry of Finance to assume primary responsibility and coordinate with the Ministry of Industry and Trade and relevant agencies in studying and carefully considering the Cassava Association's recommendations and problems.

Mr. Tien stated that the state now has a favorable policy for cassava exports that includes a zero-tax rate and a value-added tax refund. Numerous firms were forced to spend money and borrow money from banks to purchase cassava for farmers while they awaited this tax refund. As a result, each enterprise must spend an average of approximately VND 2 billion per day during the harvest season to purchase 500-1000 tons of cassava tubers for farmers.

Failure to refund and collect debts will drive cassava firms to the verge of bankruptcy. As a result, cassava firms will be reluctant to export and purchase cassava from farmers; factories will be kept idle, incurring expenses; they will be unable to repay bank loans, and bankruptcy would certainly occur. On the other side, this will result in the default of 1.2 million cassava farmers, as no one would buy their cassava.

The General Department of Taxation's issuing of Official Letter No. 2495/TCT-TTKT on July 8, 2021, and Official Letter No. 632/TCT-TTKT on March 7, 2022, barring tax refunds and collection of tax arrears has crushed the cassava sector and pushed cassava firms to the brink of collapse.

Author: Huy Binh

Translated by Linh Linh

Net Zero - A distant goal coming closer: Prioritizing carbon credit generation and sustainable forest management

Net Zero - A distant goal coming closer: Prioritizing carbon credit generation and sustainable forest management

(VAN) Forest owners must standardize processes right from the stages of seed selection and planting to adapt CBAM, EUDR regulations.

USGC meets with Saudi Arabian feed, starch sector leaders

USGC meets with Saudi Arabian feed, starch sector leaders

(VAN) The program was an opportunity for the USGC to discuss its strategies in the region as well as a chance to highlight the superior performance of US corn in both industries.

Chinese scientists find new method to sweeten tomatoes

Chinese scientists find new method to sweeten tomatoes

(VAN) The researchers from the Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences conducted taste tests on over 100 varieties of tomatoes and identified 33 flavor compounds that affect consumer preferences.

Digital climate advisory services for agriculture: Opportunities and challenges for Vietnam

Digital climate advisory services for agriculture: Opportunities and challenges for Vietnam

(VAN) Despite proving beneficial to farmers in weather forecasting, pest and disease forecasting, decision support, etc., digital services in agriculture still need more time to become more sustainable, especially when adapting to emerging challenges.

Emissions from exports account for over one-third of Vietnam’s total emissions

Emissions from exports account for over one-third of Vietnam’s total emissions

(VAN) The World Bank (WB) has identified numerous obstacles that Vietnam encounters as a result of its continuous export-oriented growth strategy.

Many World Bank-funded agricultural projects achieve positive results

Many World Bank-funded agricultural projects achieve positive results

(VAN) On November 22, Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development Le Minh Hoan met with Manuela V. Ferro, the World Bank's Regional Vice President.

Changing technology to improve the quality of exported tea

Changing technology to improve the quality of exported tea

(VAN) Investing comprehensively in technology, Vietnam's exported tea can enhance its competitiveness and establish its position in the international market.

Read more